In Season 7, Episode 8—which aired on June 10—the Islanders took part in the “Pucker or Pie” challenge. Each person had to pick a “juicy question card” and answer which Islander best fit the description. A flip of a giant coin then decided whether they got to kiss each other or throw a whipped-cream pie into the other’s face.

‘Love Island: USA’ Fans React to Cierra Ortega’s Tone-Deaf TikTok Video: ‘This Was a Hard Watch’ first appeared on Parade on Jul 15, 2025 This story was originally reported by Parade on Jul 15, 2025, where it first appeared.